The Times versus the Socialist Worker
Why would a high profile columnist and broadcaster want to spend a Sunday afternoon in Manchester slagging off the Socialist Worker newspaper?
It's odd - but it's what David Aaronovitch of The Times did at a debate on art and politics in the Town Hall yesterday.
As one of four platform speakers he launched two-attacks on Socialist Worker claiming that he was taking on the orthodoxy of the art world.
As I pointed out from the floor, using your celebrity to monster a small-circulation newspaper, that has no marketing apart from sellers outside stations on a Saturday, is hardly unorthodox.
In fact, I said, it is the strong bullying the weak - an all too familiar feature of our society.
Aaronovitch responded by ridiculing me for being a current or former member of the SWP.
As it turns out I'm not and I never have been.
So I shouted this out from the floor and an exchange ensued.
After listening to what seemed like hours of pretentious twaddle I snapped.
I thought to myself: "You want performance art. Here's some." And started ranting. A personal attack based on an assumption about my politics had no place at such a high-minded event, I suggested..
I don't know why I always make such a show of myself. It must be the artist in me.
But I was comforted by a woman who came up at the end and said: "Well done. I'm a Greek Cypriot so I know exactly how you feel."
She was obviously a surrealist too.
Earlier I'd won applause from the audience for tangling with a bigwig from Liverpool University who claimed The Clash album London Calling was a great work of art because it wasn't very political.
This series of debates - part of the Manchester International Festival - is worth a look.
If I go to any more I'll try to bite my lip.
I was really riled by Aaronovitch because "make no assumptions" is the first lesson at journalism school. It is a travesty that such a bad exponent of our craft should receive so much reward from it.

10 Comments:
I always think that it says a lot about Aaronovitch (and Cohen et al) that they spend so much time droning on about the SWP when they have absolutely no real influence on British politics, and didn't have much in their 1970s heyday.
It's just an easy target for him I suppose. But well done anyway!
Heh. Nice one Miles. A long-held ambition of mine is to give DA a public blepsing such as you did. He's not an NUJ member, Aaranovitch, of course - which is a shame, as a place on one of the union's training courses wouldn't go amiss for him
So, it was you, the brave gentleman! Nice to come across your blog. In case you don't yet know, your entry is linked to the BBC Manchester Blog project, as well as mine (I'm taking part of the project). Here are the links:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/manchester/2007/07/manchester_international_festi_4.shtml
http://loscuadernosdejulia.blogspot.com/2007/07/politics-of-art-after-debate.html
Hope you enjoyed it, and perhaps see you at another debate?
All best, JD
David Aaranovitch is one of my fave journalists!!
Fucking graduates! With no fucking NCJT. Just a spoiling forward in life's rugby match. No good so stops others playing.
But the SWP paper is pretty shit isn't it? Really?
It was when Aaronovitch was a student and hack here. Difference was they only had about four members in Greater Manchester then.
NJCT?
NO, I said NCJT!
National Council for the Training of Journalists.
tibia money tibia gold tibia item runescape money runescape gold tibia money tibia gold runescape gold runescape accounts tibia gold tibia money runescape money runescape gp buy runescape gold tibia gold tibia item buy runescape money runescape gold runescape items tibia money tibia gold
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home